SERVICE RESTATES OBJECTIVES AND STANDARDS FOR PUBLICATION OF REVENUE RULINGS AND REVENUE PROCEDURES.

Rev. Proc. 89-14

SECTION 1. PURPOSE

This revenue procedure supercedes Rev. Proc. 86-15, 1986-1C.B. 544, and makes the changes described in section 2 below. The revenue procedure restates the objectives of, and sets forth the standards for, the publication of revenue rulings and revenue procedures in the Internal Revenue Bulletin.

SECTION 2. CHANGES

Section 7.01(5) of Rev. Proc. 86-15 provides that because each revenue ruling represents the conclusion of the Service as to the application of the law to the entire statement of facts involved, taxpayer, Service personnel, and others concerned are cautioned against reaching the same conclusion in other cases unless the facts and circumstances are substantially the same. This caution, which now appears in section 7.01(6) of this revenue procedure, has been clarified. It now explicitly warns that, if from the facts, legal analysis, or other discussion it is clear that the federal tax law conclusion of the revenue ruling or revenue procedure is predicated upon a certain provision or interpretation of law other than federal tax law, then those seeking to rely on that conclusion must check to see whether such relevant nontax law has changed materially from that used in the revenue ruling or revenue procedure.

Section 7.01(7) of the revenue procedure is revised to add a statement which encourages all interested parties to submit suggestions of generic issues that would be appropriately addressed in revenue rulings or revenue procedures.

Section 8l01 is revised to reflect the fact that the Assistant Commissioner (Taxpayer Service and Returns Processing) is now responsible for publishing the Internal Revenue Bulletin.

SEC. 3. DEFINITIONS

01 A "revenue ruling" is an official interpretation by the Service of the internal revenue laws and related statutes, treaties, and regulations, that has been published in the Bulletin. Revenue rulings are issued only by the National Office and are published for the information and guidance of taxpayers, Service officials, and others concerned.

02 A "revenue procedure" is an official statement of a procedure published in the Bulletin that either affects the rights or duties of taxpayers or other members of the public under the Internal Revenue Code and related statutes, treaties, and regulations or, although not necessarily affecting the rights and duties of the public, should be a matter of public knowledge.

SEC. 4. BACKGROUND

01 The Bulletin is the authoritative instrument of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue for the publication of official rulings and procedures of the Service, including all rulings and statements of procedure that supercede, revoke, modify, amend, or affect any previously published ruling or procedure. The Service also announces in the Bulletin the Commissioner's acquiescence or nonacquiescence in decisions of the United States Tax court (other than decisions in memorandum opinions), and publishes Treasury Decisions, Executive Orders, tax conventions, legislation, court decisions, and other items considered to be of general interest.

02 The Bulletin is published weekly. In order to provide a permanent reference source, the contents of the Bulletin are consolidated semiannually into an indexed Cumulative Bulletin. These materials are sold by the Superintendent of Documents, U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, D.C. 20402-9325.

SEC. 5. OBJECTIVES

The purpose of publication of revenue rulings and revenue procedures in the Bulletin is to promote uniform application of the tax laws by Service employees and to assist taxpayers in attaining maximum voluntary compliance by informing Service personnel and the public of National Office interpretations of the internal revenue laws, related statutes, treaties, and regulations, and statements of Service procedures affecting the rights and duties of taxpayers.

SEC. 6 PUBLICATION STANDARDS

01 It is the policy of the Service to publish in the Bulletin issues and answers involving substantive tax laws under the jurisdiction of the Service, except those involving -

(1) Issues answered by statute, treaties, or regulations;

(2) Issues answered by rulings, opinions, or court decisions previously published in the Bulletin;

(3) Issues that are of insufficient importance or interest to warrant publication;

(4) Determinations of fact rather than interpretations of law;

(5) Informers and informers' rewards; and

(6) Disclosure of secret formulas, processes, business practices, and similar information.

02 It is the policy of the Service to publish in the Bulletin procedures affecting taxpayers' rights or duties that relate to matters under the jurisdiction of the Service.

SEC. 7. FORM AND EFFECT OF PUBLICATION

01 Revenue Rulings.

(1) Rulings and other communications involving substantive tax law published in the Bulletin are published in the form of revenue rulings. The conclusions expressed in a revenue ruling will be directly responsive to, and limited in scope by, the pivotal facts stated in the revenue ruling. Revenue rulings arise from various sources, including rulings to taxpayers, technical advice to district offices, court decisions, suggestions from tax practitioner groups, publications, etc.

(2) If the revenue ruling arises from the circumstances of a particular taxpayer, the SErvice published as much as is necessary for an understanding of the position stated. However, identifying details, including the names and addresses of persons involved, and information of a confidential nature are not included, to prevent unwarranted invasions of personal privacy and to comply with statutory provisions, such as 18 U.S.C. section 1905 and 26 U.S.C. sections 6103 and 7213, dealing with disclosure of information obtained from members of the public.

(3) A revenue ruling, other than one relating to the qualification of pension, annuity, profit-sharing, stock bonus, and bond purchase plans, applies retroactively, unless it includes a specific statement indicating, under the authority of section 7805(b) of the Code, the extent to which it is to be applied without retroactive effect. When revenue rulings revoke or modify rulings previously published in the Bulletin, the authority of section 7805(b) ordinarily is invoked to provide that the new rulings will not be applied retroactively to the extent that the new rulings have adverse tax consequences to taxpayers. Section 7805(b) provides that the Secretary of the Treasury may prescribe the extent to which any ruling is to be applied without retroactive effect. That authority has been delegated to the Commissioner and has been delegated to the Associate Chief Counsel (Technical), the Associate Chief Counsel (International), and the Assistant Commissioner (Employee Plans and Exempt Organizations) and to each of their deputies. The exercise of this authority requires an affirmative action. For the effect of revenue rulings on determination letters and opinion letters issued with respect to the qualification of pension, annuity, profit- sharing, stock bonus, and bond purchase plans, see section 13 of Rev. Proc. 80-30, 1980-1 C.B. 685.

(4) Revenue rulings published in the Bulletin do not have the force and effect of Treasury Department regulations (including Treasury Decisions), but are published to provide precedents to be used in the disposition of other cases, and may be cited and relied upon for that purpose. No published ruling or decision will be relied on, used, or cited, by any officer or employee of the Service as a precedent in the disposition of other cases.

(5) Taxpayer generally may rely upon revenue rulings and revenue procedures published in the Bulletin in determining the tax treatment of their own transactions and need not request specific rulings applying the principles of a published revenue ruling or revenue procedure to the facts of their particular cases. However, taxpayer, Service personnel, and other concerned are also cautioned to determine whether a revenue ruling or revenue procedure on which they seek to rely has been revoked, modified, declared obsolete, distinguished, clarified, or otherwise affected by subsequent legislation, treaties, regulations, revenue rulings, revenue procedures or court decisions.

(6) Each revenue ruling represents the conclusion of the Service as to the application of the law to the entire statement of facts involved. Therefore, taxpayers, Service personnel, and others concerned are cautioned against reaching the same conclusion in other cases unless the facts and circumstances are substantially the same. For example, occasionally, from the facts, legal analysis, or other discussion it is clear that the federal tax law conclusion of the revenue ruling or revenue procedure is predicated upon a certain provision or interpretation of law other than federal tax law. If so, taxpayers, Service personnel, and others concerned are also cautioned to determine whether such relevant nontax law has changed materially from that used in the revenue ruling or revenue procedure on which they seek to rely. In some cases, if the conclusion of a revenue ruling or revenue procedure is so predicated on such nontax law, the ruling or procedure may caution taxpayers by referring to this paragraph of this revenue procedure. Any absence, however, of such a caution does not prevent the principles stated here from applying to that revenue ruling or revenue procedure.

(7) All interested parties, including teachers, professional associations, and trade or business groups are encouraged to submit suggestions of generic issues that would be appropriately addressed in revenue rulings or revenue procedures. Also, comments and suggestions from taxpayer, taxpayer groups, or other interested parties, on revenue rulings or revenue procedures being prepared for publication in the Bulletin may be solicited if justified by special circumstances. Conferences on revenue rulings or revenue procedures being prepared for publication will not be granted except when the Service determines that such action is justified by special circumstances.

02 Revenue Procedures. When revenue procedures reflect the contents of internal management document, it is Service practice to publish as much of the internal management document as is necessary for an understanding of the procedure. When publication of the substance of a revenue procedure in the Federal Register is required pursuant to 5 U.S.C. section 552, it will usually be accomplished by an amendment of the Statement of Procedural Rules (26 C.F.R. Part 601).

SEC. 8. RESPONSIBILITIES

01 The Chief Counsel is responsible for administering the Service's revenue ruling and revenue procedure publication program including the standards for style and format revenue rulings and revenue procedures. The Assistant Commissioner (Taxpayer Service and Returns Processing) is responsible for publishing the Internal Revenue Bulletin weekly and for consolidating the contents of the Bulletin semiannually into an indexed Cumulative Bulletin.

02 In accordance with the standards set forth in section 6 of this revenue procedure, the Associate Chief Counsel (Technical), the Associate Chief Counsel (International), and the Assistant Commissioner (Employee Plans and Exempt Organizations) are responsible for the preparation and appropriate referral for publication of revenue rulings reflecting interpretations of substantive tax law made by their respective offices.

03 In accordance with the standards set forth in section 6 of this revenue procedure, all Assistant Commissioners and the Chief Counsel are responsible for the determination of whether procedures established by any office under their jurisdiction should be published as revenue procedures and for the initiation, content, and appropriate referral for publication of such revenue procedures.

SEC. 9. EFFECT ON OTHER DOCUMENTS

Rev. Proc. 86-15 is superseded.

DRAFTING INFORMATION

This revenue procedure was drafted by the Office of the Associate Chief Counsel (Passthroughs and Special Industries). For further information regarding this revenue procedure contact Mr. James F. Hogan on (202) 566-3502 (not a toll-free call).